I can draw to raise funds…
Random draw, batching, digital archery; it’s been a challenge trying to find a method for prioritizing the new gTLD applications but ICANN have finally come up with, “an equitable and reliable method”, a random draw.
Yes, you read correctly, ICANN have gone full circle and returned to their original plan, announcing the Draw on October 10. When a random draw was first suggested, ICANN rejected the idea as they were concerned it would violate California’s anti-lottery laws. Following the negative reception batching and then digital archery received they have found a loophole in the law; they have applied for a fundraising drawing’s license, meaning non-profit organizations may conduct fundraising lotteries. Fundraising for what, we may never know.
With applicants eager to receive a prompt evaluation of their domains, there may still be reason for concern as ICANN await the result of their license application. The license, if granted, will arrive towards the end of November; should the license request be rejected ICANN have announced they will hold a contest. Details of this contest are unavailable but with previous complaints from applicants regarding the unfairness of digital archery, ICANN may struggle to find the perfect solution. Although there were helpful suggestions from the applicants during the comment period proposed games of skill/chance as a way to prioritize the applications such as rock, paper, scissors.
The Draw and how much it will raise
The Draw, if the license is granted, is a manual process (so no technical glitches, this time) and will assign a Draw number to each applicant; the number will determine the schedule for initial evaluation and the release of evaluation results. The lowest Draw numbers will be released first after the IDNs. ICANN plans to use a third-party to oversee the Draw which will occur between 4-15 December, the exact date is still to be confirmed.
The license for the Draw will specify that each applicant shall purchase a paper ticket; the ticket must be purchased in person, in California. Because not all applicants will be able or willing to make the trip, a representative can be appointed either by the applicant or, ICANN will provide an independent representative. Due to the license rules, ICANN are not permitted to sell the tickets via the Internet. Draw numbers must not be exchanged between applications or applicants; unfortunately this means that applicants with a portfolio of domains will not be able to prioritize their applications. Please read Drawing for Prioritizing for more detailed information.
The price of the Draw tickets is likely to be $100 (1930 applications possibly adding a tidy sum to the ‘fundraising pot’); having already paid $185,000, a few more dollars is a drop in the ocean.
Don’t want to play?
There is no obligation for applicants to participate in the ‘fundraising’ draw and should this be the case, their applications will be assigned randomly at the end. But, with all the delays to date, applicants’ costs are increasing; those in the same field of business will suffer if one is favoured over another, so opt-out is not something to be considered.
Priority already given to 116
ICANN has decided that IDNs (Internationalized Domain Names) will receive priority with an early release. ICANN’s mission has always been to serve the public interest globally and the release of IDNs will ensure the Internet is more accessible to users in countries that do not use the Latin script and therefore have been limited in their use of the Internet.
There are 116 IDN applications awaiting evaluation.
Predicted predictions
ICANN have stated that the first of the evaluation results will be released in late March and finishing towards the end of June, beginning of July. Good news then, six months earlier than recent estimates; but wait, originally the delegation of gTLDs was planned for autumn, 2012.
It is planned for the Draw numbers to eventually be used to schedule appointments for pre-delegation testing and executing agreements; with approximately 20 pre-delegation testing appointments and 20 contracts executed per week. ICANN have stated, “No contracts will be fully executed or delegations made prior to the ICANN meeting in Beijing (April 7-11, 2013).”
If you don’t comment, you can’t complain
To proceed with the Draw, ICANN require approval from the state of California and the applicants; ICANN have opened a 30-day forum for public comments; scheduled from October 10 until November 9, it should make for an interesting read.
EuroDNS in Toronto
The ICANN meeting, that took place in Toronto this week, was attended by delegates from the EuroDNS team; as one can imagine, the current situation with the new gTLDs will have been on everyone’s lips. Any interesting or important information will be published in the EuroDNS newsletter, so please subscribe to ensure you stay fully informed.
Random draw, batching, digital archery; it’s been a challenge trying to find a method for prioritizing the new gTLD applications but ICANN have finally come up with, “an equitable and reliable method”, a random draw.
Yes, you read correctly, ICANN have gone full circle and returned to their original plan, announcing the Draw on October 10. When a random draw was first suggested, ICANN rejected the idea as they were concerned it would violate California’s anti-lottery laws. Following the negative reception batching and then digital archery received they have found a loophole in the law; they have applied for a fundraising drawing’s license, meaning non-profit organizations may conduct fundraising lotteries. Fundraising for what, we may never know.
With applicants eager to receive a prompt evaluation of their domains, there may still be reason for concern as ICANN await the result of their license application. The license, if granted, will arrive towards the end of November; should the license request be rejected ICANN have announced they will hold a contest. Details of this contest are unavailable but with previous complaints from applicants regarding the unfairness of digital archery, ICANN may struggle to find the perfect solution. Although there were helpful suggestions from the applicants during the comment period proposed games of skill/chance as a way to prioritize the applications such as rock, paper, scissors.
The Draw and how much it will raise
The Draw, if the license is granted, is a manual process (so no technical glitches, this time) and will assign a Draw number to each applicant; the number will determine the schedule for initial evaluation and the release of evaluation results. The lowest Draw numbers will be released first after the IDNs. ICANN plans to use a third-party to oversee the Draw which will occur between 4-15 December, the exact date is still to be confirmed.
The license for the Draw will specify that each applicant shall purchase a paper ticket; the ticket must be purchased in person, in California. Because not all applicants will be able or willing to make the trip, a representative can be appointed either by the applicant or, ICANN will provide an independent representative. Due to the license rules, ICANN are not permitted to sell the tickets via the Internet. Draw numbers must not be exchanged between applications or applicants; unfortunately this means that applicants with a portfolio of domains will not be able to prioritize their applications. Please read Drawing for Prioritizing for more detailed information.
The price of the Draw tickets is likely to be $100 (1930 applications possibly adding a tidy sum to the ‘fundraising pot’); having already paid $185,000, a few more dollars is a drop in the ocean.
Don’t want to play?
There is no obligation for applicants to participate in the ‘fundraising’ draw and should this be the case, their applications will be assigned randomly at the end. But, with all the delays to date, applicants’ costs are increasing; those in the same field of business will suffer if one is favoured over another, so opt-out is not something to be considered.
Priority already given to 116
ICANN has decided that IDNs (Internationalized Domain Names) will receive priority with an early release. ICANN’s mission has always been to serve the public interest globally and the release of IDNs will ensure the Internet is more accessible to users in countries that do not use the Latin script and therefore have been limited in their use of the Internet.
There are 116 IDN applications awaiting evaluation.
Predicted predictions
ICANN have stated that the first of the evaluation results will be released in late March and finishing towards the end of June, beginning of July. Good news then, six months earlier than recent estimates; but wait, originally the delegation of gTLDs was planned for autumn, 2012.
It is planned for the Draw numbers to eventually be used to schedule appointments for pre-delegation testing and executing agreements; with approximately 20 pre-delegation testing appointments and 20 contracts executed per week. ICANN have stated, “No contracts will be fully executed or delegations made prior to the ICANN meeting in Beijing (April 7-11, 2013).”
If you don’t comment, you can’t complain
To proceed with the Draw, ICANN require approval from the state of California and the applicants; ICANN have opened a 30-day forum for public comments; scheduled from October 10 until November 9, it should make for an interesting read.
EuroDNS in Toronto
The ICANN meeting, that took place in Toronto this week, was attended by delegates from the EuroDNS team; as one can imagine, the current situation with the new gTLDs will have been on everyone’s lips. Any interesting or important information will be published in the EuroDNS newsletter, so please subscribe to ensure you stay fully informed.
